Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Peter Sim's avatar

I have been thinking a bit more on the roles of SEGM, Therapy First and Genspect. All three play and important role but they all operate under limitations which flow from their focus and mandate. SEGM is a scientific organization and its credibility is based on its commitment to promoting rigorous research. It has to be careful not to outrun the science or get involved in issues of public policy. Therapy First is trying to help patients by educating therapists to work within the existing system. The problem it faces is that there are limits to what can be done to help patients within a system that is broken. Gender ideology still dominates most major mental health organizations and conversion therapy laws and policies are being interpreted in ways that constrain what should be normal mental health practice. Genspect is an advocacy organization which can challenge the dominance of transgender ideology in governments, universities and professional groups. The problem it faces is that the language and approach which is most effective in political campaigning is often not appropriate in scientific and clinical discussion.

Peter Sim's avatar

I made some changes to the section on Therapy First. It was pointed out to me that I did not sufficiently explain the position set out in the Therapy First FAQ. I apologize for any misunderstanding.

2 more comments...

Ready for more?